James Novak looked up as a man in his mid fifties and a business suit walked into the room. His first impression was that this was a man accustomed to being listened to. On his heels was a woman who couldn't have been far out of her teen years. He couldn't even identity the color of her hair. What struck him was her eyes and the strong, tired look in her face. She had seen more in her life than most, more joy and more sadness.
“Castiel. My name is Aaron Hotchner I'm with the FBI.” The man said taking a seat.
“I'd like to ask you a few questions, is that alright?”
“What is your friends name?” Castiel replied instead.
“My name is Sasha Jordan Scott. Is Dean the only one who calls you 'Cass'?”
Castiel sat straight up in his chair. “How do you know that?”
“Dean has referred to you by that name three times in the last 45 minutes.” Aaron Hotchner answered. “Is it reserved for him?”
“No, Sam calls me that rather frequently.” He looked from the FBI agent to the woman and back again. “What is your purpose here?”
“To try to get you to stop killing people. To find out why Sam is hunting these people, what makes them monsters in the eyes of the Winchesters and to discover why you are with them.”
“Most of that I can agree with. But I'm not convinced talking to you is a good idea.”
“Because you think you can't get through to us? Or because Dean wouldn't like it if you talked to us?” Hotchner inquired.
“Because for all your honorable intent you don't understand the Winchesters. And there is no way to convince you of the truth.” Castiel said sharply. He took a short breath.
“And because Dean asked me not to say anything.” He finished lamely.
“I think you'll be more inclined to answer my questions.” Sasha prompted. “They are slightly more informed than what you would here from Hotchner's team.”
“I make no promises.” Castiel responded, considering her carefully. “But go on.”
“How long has it been since Jimmy Novak's soul ascended to heaven?” Castiel sat up even straighter than he had been. Hotchner performed a similar maneuver. “None of the three of you have ever met me before. But I do feel like I know you, for whatever reason. I know you consider yourself the Winchesters guardian. I know you were super worried Dean was still especially pissed at you at one point but when it was all over he tried to defend you. I know only two things seem to matter to you: what Dean thinks of you, and Dean himself. I know you didn't like Sam at first but he taught you a lot. Dean may be the righteous man but they are both good men. Now please tell me, how long has it been since the cemetery?” As if to make some sort of a point she holds her right hand next to her head and snaps her fingers once. The gesture must mean something because Novak's face instantly calms, his entire body seems to calm, thoughtful and purposeful. “Five years.”
“Emmanuel.” James Novak nods.
“Clarence.” Another nod.
“Gadreel.” Novak starts but nods, wordlessly.
“Hannah.” For the first time since he was brought into the station the man looks uncomfortable. As if he just now realized the woman across from him should not know
any of these things.
Sasha for her part seems to have retreated into herself slightly. Her hand to her chin, as if deep in thought. She squeezed her lips tight. “Hotch, we have two people we need to find right the hell now.”
“Amelia and Claire Novak.” Hotch said without hesitation.
“No! You leave them alone.” Castiel demanded, his voice low, almost thunderous.
“You do remember them?” Hotchner says with no small amount of surprise.
“He's suddenly feeling bad about his vessels family.” Sasha noted, almost absently.
“What. Are you. Doing?!” Castiel growled, punching out almost every single word.
“You misunderstand me Castiel.” Sasha said softly. “I'm not trying to threaten you.”
“And neither are we.” Hotchner interjected, trying to force some semblance of reason into the conversation. “We just want to make sure they're safe. And at the risk of sounding like a complete and utter douche bag. Dao si obećanje Džimiju. Pokušaću da ti pomognem da ispuniš to obećanje.” She stood up and walked out of the room.
Aaron Hotchner or 'Hotch' as most of his team called him waited a few moments. He pushed his chair back away from the table. “What did she say?”
“I...I don't understand.” The man was all but frozen in place. His eyes seemed to be the only thing working besides his jaw. “I don't understand.”
Sensing they weren't going to get anything else out of the man, Aaron stood turned, and walked out of the room.
Castiel looked down at his hands, and then up at the one way mirror. His assurance at apparently having found an ally undercut by his confusion at the detail of that ally's knowledge. This woman, Sasha had not only known Jimmy Novak was quite literally no longer with him, she had even known to call Jimmy his vessel. Most concerning, she knew the exact moment he had been atomized by Lucifer. Lucifer, who, possessing Sam's body had merely snapped his fingers once and ripped his body, his vessel – Jimmy Novak – to shreds. 'you made a promise to Jimmy. I will try to help you keep it.'
“..Then we have to find a way to reach Jimmy Novak.” Hotchner concluded.
“Castiel.” Sasha interjected. Hotchner, JJ and Prentiss all looked up at her. “If you want to get anywhere with these guys, call him Castiel. It's what he prefers to be called. You should call him that for that reason alone. As far as the man in there is concerned Jame Novak died 5 years ago!”
“You mean we have to join the narrative in order to fight them?” Rossi's comment drew a vague, tight smile from their friend.
“I'm saying you have to approach the narrative from their standpoint rather than your own. These guys are the hero of their own story and their lives have given them a master class at seeing through other people's bullshit. Castiel is practically autistic which means he reads people as clearly as I do.”
“I've been meaning to ask you about that.” Reid admits.
“Discerner of the motivations and intentions of the heart. Everything that is not of the body. I read body language like words but...”
“You feel everything as clearly as if it was directed at you.” The unit chief Aaron Hotchner surmises.
“Being around someone like Morgan actually makes me a little nauseous. Intense, unrestrained, unfiltered, if there weren't so many other input patterns in the room you would feel destructive.”
“Input patterns?” JJ asked, suddenly struggling to keep up with the conversation.
“The multiple sources in the room. And the stabilizing influence some of us are having on you.” Reid clarified.
“JJ is a protector, and a mother twice over. Protects her family and her team. Her emotions are natural, even if they can't always come out. Rossi and Prentiss are very schooled. I couldn't get a read on either of them if I tried. The very fact that they keep such a tight rein on their emotions means there's not much there for me to read. I can give generalizations. You're both professionals and in your own ways a lot like soldiers. Duty, honor, sheep dogs.”
“Sheep dogs?” JJ queried.
“Happy and normal until someone attacks your flock. Which is where this ties back into your case.”
“I was wondering when we were going to get back to that.” Morgan huffed.
“Castiel considers himself the Winchesters guardian, their protector. He honors your work, what you attempt to do day in and day out. He's just shaking his head that you are so completely wrong about who he considers to be righteous men. Or at least Good men. Don't try to reach Jimmy Novak. Try to get through to Castiel. And by the way, the Winchesters didn't do that. At least, not intentionally.”
“Do I want to know?” Aaron Hotchner and David Rossi asked simultaneously.
“If you ask the question I'll assume the answer is yes.” Sasha replied, a bite to her voice that hadn't been there before.
Reid raised his hands. “Actually we should stop to think about whether any of us even DO want to know. And apply what we've learned to the case..to the people,” He corrected himself “..in the holding cells.”
“I'm all for that.” Prentiss acknowledged.
Her comment effectively ended the conversation as everyone who wasn't already standing stood up, gathered files and made their way out the door.
Hotchner walked up to Sasha. He didn't speak right away. “I did notice you kept throwing some, surreptitious glances my way while you were talking about being an empath. Am I easy for you to read?”
“Yes but, it wouldn't have been respectful to share publicly what I get from you. It is too easily misinterpreted. Or seen as a violation of privacy. Justifiably so.”
“I appreciate it.”
“It wasn't just for your sake Aaron. I don't need these people hating me because I violate personal boundaries.”
“Still, I appreciate it. What do you sense from me?”
“The part relevant to this case? Castiel would see you as a kindred spirit. He is a warrior of God, a solider. At one time he would have done whatever it took to accomplish his mission. And that still drives him. And yes I am talking about Castiel not you. But it describes you as well, doesn't it?”
Aaron Hotchner didn't answer. He knew there wasn't the need.